NAV

Sunday, August 30, 2015

G.R. No. 179918 SHELL PHILIPPINES EXPLORATION B.V., represented by its Managing Director, Jeremy Cliff, Petitioner,......



Republic of the Philippines
SUPREME COURT
Manila
SECOND DIVISION
G.R. No. 179918               September 8, 2010
SHELL PHILIPPINES EXPLORATION B.V., represented by its Managing Director, Jeremy Cliff, Petitioner,
vs.
EFREN JALOS, JOVEN CAMPANG, ARNALDO MIJARES, CARLITO TRIVINO, LUCIANO ASERON, CHARLITO ALDOVINO, ROBERTO FADERA, RENATO MANTALA, GERTRUDES MENESES, NORBERTO HERNANDEZ, JOSE CABASE, DANILO VITTO, EDWIN MARIN, SAMUEL MARIN, ARMANDO MADERA, EDGARDO MARINO, HERMINO RELOX, ROLANDO TARROBACO, ERNESTO RELOX, ROSALITO RUGAS, ELDIE DIMALIBOT, PLARIDEL MUJE, REYMUNDO CARMONA, RONILO RIOFLORIDO, LEONIDES MANCIA, JONAR GERANCE, RODEL CASAPAO, CARMENCITA MENDOZA, SEVERINO MEDRANO, EDWIN MENDOZA, DOMINEZ SANTIAGO, ROGER MUJE, REYNALDO MORALES, WILLIAM MENDOZA, NELSON SOLIS, ALBERTO MATRE, MARGARITO GADO, BONIFACIO LEOTERIO, NEMESIO PEREZ, JR., ARIEL MENDOZA, PEPITO MENDOZA, SALVADOR FALCULAN, JR., CEASAR ROBLEDO, SUZIMO CERNA, VIRGILIO VATAL, JIMMY ALBAO, CRISANTO SABIDA, LAUDRINO MIRANDA, LEOPOLDO MISANA, JIMMY DELACION, FREJEDO MAGPILI, ROLANDO DIMALIBOT, PEDRO MAPALAD, FAUSTINO BALITOSTOS, LEONARDO DIMALIBOT, MARIANO MAGYAYA, RAUL MIRANO, ERNESTO MATRE, ROMEO ROBLEDO, GILBERT SADICON, ROMEO SIENA, NESTOR SADICON, NOEL SIENA, REDENTER CAMPANG, ARNEL HERNENDEZ, RESTITUTO BAUTISTA, JOSE MUJE, DANILO BILARMINO, ADRIAN MAGANGO, VALERIANO SIGUE, BERNIE MORALES, JOSEPH SALAZAR, PABLITO MENDOZA, JR., ERWIN BAUTISTA, RUBEN BAUTISTA, ALEXANDER ROVERO, EDUARDO QUARTO, RUBEN RIOFLORIDO, NESTOR DELACION, SEVERINO MEDRANO, JOEY FAJECULAY, NICOLAS MEDRANO, FELIX MEDRANO, RODELIO CASAPAO, FELIPE LOLONG, MARCELINO LOLONG, ELDY DIMALIBOT, ROBERTO CASAPAO, SIMEON CASAPAO, HENRY DIMALIBOT, RONALDO MORALES, PEPING CASAPAO, JOEL GERANCE, JAYREE DIMALIBOT, MARIO DIMALIBOT, SANTO DIMALIBOT, ZERAPIN DIMALIBOT, FLORENCIO ROVERO, Respondents.
D E C I S I O N
ABAD, J.:
This case is about a question of jurisdiction over an action against a petroleum contractor, whose pipeline operation has allegedly driven the fish away from coastal areas, inflicting loss of earnings among fishermen.
The Facts and the Case
On December 11, 1990 petitioner Shell Philippines Exploration B.V. (Shell) and the Republic of the Philippines entered into Service Contract 38 for the exploration and extraction of petroleum in northwestern Palawan. Two years later, Shell discovered natural gas in the Camago-Malampaya area and pursued its development of the well under the Malampaya Natural Gas Project. This entailed the construction and installation of a pipeline from Shell’s production platform to its gas processing plant in Batangas. The pipeline spanned 504 kilometers and crossed the Oriental Mindoro Sea.
On May 19, 2003, respondents Efren Jalos, Joven Campang, Arnaldo Mijares, and 75 other individuals (Jalos, et al) filed a complaint for damages1 against Shell before the Regional Trial Court (RTC), Branch 41, Pinamalayan, Oriental Mindoro. Jalos, et al claimed that they were all subsistence fishermen from the coastal barangay of Bansud, Oriental Mindoro whose livelihood was adversely affected by the construction and operation of Shell’s natural gas pipeline.
Jalos, et al claimed that their fish catch became few after the construction of the pipeline. As a result, their average net income per month fell from a high of P4,848.00 to only P573.00. They said that "the pipeline greatly affected biogenically hard-structured communities such as coral reefs and led [to] stress to the marine life in the Mindoro Sea." They now have to stay longer and farther out at sea to catch fish, as the pipeline’s operation has driven the fish population out of coastal waters.2
Instead of filing an answer, Shell moved for dismissal of the complaint. It alleged that the trial court had no jurisdiction over the action, as it is a "pollution case" under Republic Act (R.A.) 3931, as amended by Presidential Decree (P.D.) 984 or the Pollution Control Law. Under these statutes, the Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB) has primary jurisdiction over pollution cases and actions for related damages.3
Shell also claimed that it could not be sued pursuant to the doctrine of state immunity without the State’s consent. Shell said that under Service Contract 38, it served merely as an agent of the Philippine government in the development of the Malampaya gas reserves.
Moreover, said Shell, the complaint failed to state a cause of action since it did not specify any actionable wrong or particular act or omission on Shell’s part that could have caused the alleged injury to Jalos, et al. The complaint likewise failed to comply with requirements of a valid class suit, verification and certification against forum shopping, and the requisites for a suit brought by pauper litigants.4
On March 24, 2004 the RTC dismissed the complaint. It ruled that the action was actually pollution-related, although denominated as one for damages. The complaint should thus be brought first before the PAB, the government agency vested with jurisdiction over pollution-related cases.5
Jalos, et al assailed the RTC’s order through a petition for certiorari6 before the Court of Appeals (CA). In due course, the latter court reversed such order and upheld the jurisdiction of the RTC over the action. It said that Shell was not being sued for committing pollution, but for constructing and operating a natural gas pipeline that caused fish decline and considerable reduction in the fishermen’s income. The claim for damages was thus based on a quasi-delict over which the regular courts have jurisdiction.
The CA also rejected Shell’s assertion that the suit was actually against the State. It observed that the government was not even impleaded as party defendant. It gave short shrift to Shell’s insistence that, under the service contract, the government was solidarily liable with Shell for damages caused to third persons. Besides, the State should be deemed to have given its consent to be sued when it entered into the contract with Shell.
The CA also held that the complaint sufficiently alleged an actionable wrong. Jalos, et al invoked their right to fish the sea and earn a living, which Shell had the correlative obligation to respect. Failure to observe such obligation resulted in a violation of the fishermen’s rights and thus gave rise to a cause of action for damages.7
Finally, the CA held that Jalos, et al substantially complied with the technical requirements for filing the action. But since they failed to prove the requisites of a class suit, only those who have verified the complaint should be deemed party plaintiffs.8
Shell moved for reconsideration of the CA’s decision but the same was denied.9 Hence, it filed this petition for review under Rule 45.
The Issues Presented
The case presents the following issues:

1. Whether or not the complaint is a pollution case that falls within the primary jurisdiction of the PAB;
2. Whether or not the complaint sufficiently alleges a cause of action against Shell; and
3. Whether or not the suit is actually against the State and is barred under the doctrine of state immunity.
The Court’s Rulings
First. Although the complaint of Jalos, et al does not use the word "pollution" in describing the cause of the alleged fish decline in the Mindoro Sea, it is unmistakable based on their allegations that Shell’s pipeline produced some kind of poison or emission that drove the fish away from the coastal areas. While the complaint did not specifically attribute to Shell any specific act of "pollution," it alleged that "the pipeline greatly affected biogenically hard-structured communities such as coral reefs and led [to] stress to the marine life in the Mindoro Sea."10 This constitutes "pollution" as defined by law.
Section 2(a) of P.D. 984 defines "pollution" as "any alteration of the physical, chemical and biological properties of any water x x x as will or is likely to create or render such water x x x harmful, detrimental or injurious to public health, safety or welfare or which will adversely affect their utilization for domestic, commercial, industrial, agricultural, recreational or other legitimate purposes."
It is clear from this definition that the stress to marine life claimed by Jalos, et al is caused by some kind of pollution emanating from Shell’s natural gas pipeline. The pipeline, they said, "greatly affected" or altered the natural habitat of fish and affected the coastal waters’ natural function as fishing grounds. Inevitably, in resolving Jalos, et al’s claim for damages, the proper tribunal must determine whether or not the operation of the pipeline adversely altered the coastal waters’ properties and negatively affected its life sustaining function. The power and expertise needed to determine such issue lies with the PAB.
Executive Order 192 (1987) transferred to the PAB the powers and functions of the National Pollution and Control Commission provided in R.A. 3931, as amended by P.D. 984.11 These empowered the PAB to "[d]etermine the location, magnitude, extent, severity, causes and effects" of water pollution.12 Among its functions is to "[s]erve as arbitrator for the determination of reparation, or restitution of the damages and losses resulting from pollution." In this regard, the PAB has the power to conduct hearings,13 impose penalties for violation of P.D. 984,14 and issue writs of execution to enforce its orders and decisions.15 The PAB’s final decisions may be reviewed by the CA under Rule 43 of the Rules of Court.16
Jalos, et al had, therefore, an administrative recourse before filing their complaint with the regular courts.17 The laws creating the PAB and vesting it with powers are wise. The definition of the term "pollution" itself connotes the need for specialized knowledge and skills, technical and scientific, in determining the presence, the cause, and the effects of pollution. These knowledge and skills are not within the competence of ordinary courts.18 Consequently, resort must first be made to the PAB, which is the agency possessed of expertise in determining pollution-related matters.1avvphil
To this extent, the failure of Jalos, et al to allege in their complaint that they had first taken resort to PAB before going to court means that they failed to state a cause of action that the RTC could act on. This warranted the dismissal of their action.19
Second. Still, Shell points out that the complaint also states no cause of action because it failed to specify any actionable wrong or particular act or omission on Shell’s part. The Court cannot agree.
As mentioned above, the complaint said that the natural gas pipeline’s construction and operation "greatly affected" the marine environment, drove away the fish, and resulted in reduced income for Jalos, et al. True, the complaint did not contain some scientific explanation regarding how the construction and operation of the pipeline disturbed the waters and drove away the fish from their usual habitat as the fishermen claimed. But lack of particulars is not a ground for dismissing the complaint.
A cause of action is the wrongful act or omission committed by the defendant in violation of the primary rights of the plaintiff.20 Its elements consist of: (1) a right existing in favor of the plaintiff, (2) a duty on the part of the defendant to respect the plaintiff’s right, and (3) an act or omission of the defendant in violation of such right.21 To sustain a motion to dismiss for lack of cause of action, however, the complaint must show that the claim for relief does not exist and not only that the claim was defectively stated or is ambiguous, indefinite or uncertain.22
Here, all the elements of a cause of action are present. First, Jalos, et al undoubtedly had the right to the preferential use of marine and fishing resources which is guaranteed by no less than the Constitution.23 Second, Shell had the correlative duty to refrain from acts or omissions that could impair Jalos, et al’s use and enjoyment of the bounties of the seas. Lastly, Shell’s construction and operation of the pipeline, which is an act of physical intrusion into the marine environment, is said to have disrupted and impaired the natural habitat of fish and resulted in considerable reduction of fish catch and income for Jalos, et al.
Thus, the construction and operation of the pipeline may, in itself, be a wrongful act that could be the basis of Jalos, et al’s cause of action. The rules do not require that the complaint establish in detail the causal link between the construction and operation of the pipeline, on the one hand, and the fish decline and loss of income, on the other hand, it being sufficient that the complaint states the ultimate facts on which it bases its claim for relief. The test for determining the sufficiency of a cause of action rests on whether the complaint alleges facts which, if true, would justify the relief demanded.24 In this case, a valid judgment for damages can be made in favor of Jalos, et al, if the construction and operation of the pipeline indeed caused fish decline and eventually led to the fishermen’s loss of income, as alleged in the complaint.
Third. Shell claims that it cannot be sued without the State’s consent under the doctrine of state immunity from suit. But, to begin with, Shell is not an agent of the Republic of the Philippines. It is but a service contractor for the exploration and development of one of the country’s natural gas reserves. While the Republic appointed Shell as the exclusive party to conduct petroleum operations in the Camago-Malampayo area under the State’s full control and supervision,25 it does not follow that Shell has become the State’s "agent" within the meaning of the law.
An agent is a person who binds himself to render some service or to do something in representation or on behalf of another, with the consent or authority of the latter.26 The essence of an agency is the agent’s ability to represent his principal and bring about business relations between the latter and third persons.27 An agent’s ultimate undertaking is to execute juridical acts that would create, modify or extinguish relations between his principal and third persons.28 It is this power to affect the principal’s contractual relations with third persons that differentiates the agent from a service contractor.
Shell’s main undertaking under Service Contract 38 is to "[p]erform all petroleum operations and provide all necessary technology and finance" as well as other connected services29 to the Philippine government. As defined under the contract, petroleum operation means the "searching for and obtaining Petroleum within the Philippines", including the "transportation, storage, handling and sale" of petroleum whether for export or domestic consumption.30 Shell’s primary obligation under the contract is not to represent the Philippine government for the purpose of transacting business with third persons. Rather, its contractual commitment is to develop and manage petroleum operations on behalf of the State.
Consequently, Shell is not an agent of the Philippine government, but a provider of services, technology and financing31 for the Malampaya Natural Gas Project. It is not immune from suit and may be sued for claims even without the State’s consent. Notably, the Philippine government itself recognized that Shell could be sued in relation to the project. This is evident in the stipulations agreed upon by the parties under Service Contract 38.
Article II, paragraph 8, Annex "B" of Service Contract 3832 states that legal expenses, including "judgments obtained against the Parties or any of them on account of the Petroleum Operations", can be recovered by Shell as part of operating expenses to be deducted from gross proceeds. Article II, paragraph 9B of the same document allows a similar recovery for "[a]ll actual expenditures incurred and paid by CONTRACTOR [Shell] in settlement of any and all losses, claims, damages, judgments, and any other expenses not covered by insurance, including legal services." This signifies that the State itself acknowledged the suability of Shell. Since payment of claims and damages pursuant to a judgment against Shell can be deducted from gross proceeds, the State will not be required to perform any additional affirmative act to satisfy such a judgment.
In sum, while the complaint in this case sufficiently alleges a cause of action, the same must be filed with the PAB, which is the government agency tasked to adjudicate pollution-related cases. Shell is not an agent of the State and may thus be sued before that body for any damages caused by its operations. The parties may appeal the PAB’s decision to the CA. But pending prior determination by the PAB, courts cannot take cognizance of the complaint.
WHEREFORE, the Court GRANTS the petition and REVERSES the decision of the Court of Appeals in CA-G.R. CV 82404 dated November 20, 2006. Respondent Efren Jalos, et al’s complaint for damages against Shell Philippines Exploration B.V. in Civil Case P-1818-03 of the Regional Trial Court, Branch 41, Pinamalayan, Oriental Mindoro is ordered DISMISSED without prejudice to its refiling with the Pollution Adjudication Board or PAB.
SO ORDERED.
ROBERTO A. ABAD
Associate Justice
WE CONCUR:
ANTONIO T. CARPIO
Associate Justice
DIOSDADO M. PERALTA
Associate Justice		MARIANO C. DEL CASTILLO*
Associate Justice
JOSE CATRAL MENDOZA
Associate Justice
A T T E S T A T I O N
I attest that the conclusions in the above Decision had been reached in consultation before the case was assigned to the writer of the opinion of the Court’s Division.
ANTONIO T. CARPIO
Associate Justice
Chairperson, Second Division
C E R T I F I C A T I O N
Pursuant to Section 13, Article VIII of the Constitution and the Division Chairperson’s Attestation, I certify that the conclusions in the above Decision had been reached in consultation before the case was assigned to the writer of the opinion of the Court’s Division.
RENATO C. CORONA
Chief Justice

Footnotes

* Designated as additional member in lieu of Associate Justice Antonio Eduardo B. Nachura, per raffle dated June 7, 2010.
1 Docketed as Civil Case P-1818-03 (also referred to as Civil Case R-1818-03 in some parts of the records).
2 Rollo, p. 119.
3 Id. at 141-143.
4 Id. at 146-157.
5 Id. at 114.
6 Docketed as CA-G.R. CV 82404.
7 Rollo, pp. 96-100.
8 Id. at 102.
9 Id. at 108-110.
10 Biogenic means "essential to life and its maintenance." (Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, Unabridged, p. 218.)
11 Estrada v. Court of Appeals, 484 Phil. 730, 742 (2004).
12 P.D. 984, Section 6(a).
13 Id., Section 6(d).
14 Id., Section (9).
15 Id., Section 7(d).
16 Id., Section 7(c).
17 The Alexandra Condominium Corporation v. Laguna Lake Development Authority, G.R. No. 169228, September 11, 2009, 599 SCRA 452, 461.
18 Mead v. Hon. Argel, 200 Phil. 650, 662 (1982).
19 Supra note 11, at 739.
20 Remedial Law Compendium, Vol. I (2002 Ed.), Justice Florenz D. Regalado. p. 66.
21 Luzon Development Bank v. Conquilla, G.R. No. 163338, September 21, 2005, 470 SCRA 533, 546.
22 Philippine Bank of Communications v. Trazo, G.R. No. 165500, August 30, 2006, 500 SCRA 242, 255.
23 Article XIII, Section 7 provides:
SEC. 7. The State shall protect the rights of subsistence fishermen, especially of local communities, to the preferential use of the communal marine and fishing resources, both inland and offshore. It shall provide support to such fishermen through appropriate technology and research, adequate financial, production, and marketing assistance, and other services. The State shall also protect, develop, and conserve such resources. The protection shall extend to offshore fishing grounds of subsistence fishermen against foreign intrusion. Fishworkers shall receive a just share from their labor in the utilization of marine and fishing resources.
24 Raytheon International, Inc. v. Rouzie, Jr., G.R. No. 162894, February 26, 2008, 546 SCRA 555, 565.
25 Rollo, p. 378.
26 Civil Code of the Philippines, Article 1869.
27 Philex Mining Corporation v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, G.R. No. 148187, April 16, 2008, 551 SCRA 428, 442.
28 Nielson & Company, Inc. v. Lepanto Consolidated Mining Company, 135 Phil. 532, 541 (1968).
29 Rollo, p. 384.
30 Id. at 380.
31 See Sections 6 and 7, Presidential Decree 87 or The Oil Exploration and Development Act of 1972.
32 Rollo, p. 403. The stipulation reads in full:
"8. Legal Expenses.
All costs and expenses of litigation, or legal service otherwise necessary or expedient for the protection of the joint interests, including attorney’s fees and expenses as hereinafter provided, together with all judgments obtained against the Parties or any of them on account of the Petroleum Operations, and actual expenses incurred in securing evidence for the purpose of defending against the Operations of the subject matter of the Contract. In the event actions or claims affecting interests under the Contract shall be handled by the legal staff not otherwise charged to Operating Expenses of one or more of the Parties, a charge commensurate with the cost of providing and furnishing such services may be made against Operating Expenses."

DOCUMENT SHARED FROM


The TRUTH will set you FREE.
Posted by at

No comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

SHELL CIRCUMVENTED RA 7641

SYNDICATED ESTAFA


MY QUEST FOR SWINDLED 

RETIREMENT PAY BY SHELL



SWINDLING ITO, SYNDICATED ESTAFA


HOT PURSUIT
DUTY OF LAW ENFORCEMENT ENTITIES


SHELL SWINDLING OF RETIREMENT PAY 5TH YEAR

1001counts
SEE BELOW FOR THE 1001ST   TIME THE REITERATION OF DEMAND PAYMENT OF RETIREMENT PAY WHICH SHELL REFUSED TO HONOR IN THE PRESENCE AND DEEMED APPROVAL OF THE HONORABLE MAGISTRATES OF THE SUPREME COURT OF THE PHILIPPINES

GEUS_15MAR16_66th FOLLOW UP_REITERATION

OF DEMAND  PAYMENT OF RETIREMENT PAY
Dishonest scales are an abomination to the Lord, but a just weight is His delight... Proverbs Chapter 11  v. 1
Retirement Pay Law circumvented by Shell subject to penal provision provided for by Article 288 of the Labor Code of the Philippines.





CONTENTS

.ENTERTAINMENT (4) 10 CCR § 2695.5 (1) 18DEC15 (112) 1A_MEDIA (8) 2014 CHRISTMAS MESSAGE (1) 2015 Miss Universe (1) 2016 SONA (1) 2020 EXCLUSION (1) 4TH OF JULY (1) abante clipping (1) ABOLITION OF THE COURT OF APPEALS (1) ABRAHAM LINCOLN (1) ABS-CBN (5) ABS-CBN NEWS (6) ABSOLUTE PARDON (1) ABU SAYAFF GROUP (2) ABUSE OF JURISDICTION (1) ACADEMIC FREEDOM (1) ACCRA (19) ACE VEDA (2) ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF EMAIL RECEIPT (2) aclu (3) AIRPORT HACKS (1) AIRWAVES (1) AIZA SEGUERRA (1) ALAN PETER CAYETANO (4) ALBAYALDE (8) ALBERTO ROMULO (1) ALDEN AND MAINE (1) Alfred Clayton (55) ALLEGATIONS OF MISCONDUCT (4) ALTERNET (6) ALVAREZ (1) ALVIN CUDIA (2) ALYAS BIKOY (1) AMADO VALDEZ (1) ANARCHY (1) ANDRES BONIFACIO (2) ANGEL LAZARO (1) ANGELO REYES (1) ANNEX 5 (5) ANNUAL REMINDERS (1) ANTHONY TABERNA . GERRY BAJA (2) ANTI GRAFT AND CORRUPT PRACTICES ACT (2) ANTI-TERRORISM ACT OF 2020 (1) ANTONIO (26) AQUACULTURE (1) AQUASCAPING (1) ARNOLD GONZALEZ (1) Arnold Schwarzenegger (5) ARTBOARD (15) ARTEMIO PANGANIBAN (1) atty dodo dulay (3) ATTY THEODORE TE (2) ATTY. AILEEN LOURDES LIZADA (3) ATTY. QUIROZ DISBARMENT (20) AUDIO (1) AUNTIE (1) AUSTRALIA (1) AUTOMATIC REPLY (1) AUTUMN LEAVES (1) AYALA (25) BAD FAITH (12) BALANGIGA (2) BANGSA MORO TRANSITION COMMISSION (1) BAR EXAM (2) BASKETBALL (1) Batangas City (2) BATANGAS PRIDE (3) BATS (1) BAUAN (5) BAUAN CENTRAL SCHOOL (4) BAUAN HIGH (1) BAUAN NEW MARKET SITE WITH GRAND TERMINAL (2) BAYAN KO (5) BAYAN MUNA (1) BAYAN NI JUAN (1) BAYAN USA (1) BBC HARDTALK (1) BBC NEWS (4) BBM (4) BEEP CARD (1) BERNADETTE ELLORIN (1) BERNIE SANDERS (5) BETRAYAL OF PUBLIC TRUST (2) BHS (2) BILL WATTERSON (1) Biodiesel topics (4) BIR (1) Bird (no music) (1) BLACK FRIDAY PROTEST (1) BLOCKED E-MAIL (2) BOMB TRAINS (2) BONFIRE (1) BONGBONG (1) BONSAI (8) BORED PANDA (3) BOYCOTT (2) brain-eating amoeba (1) BREAKING SILENCE (2) Brian Ross (1) BRICKS ON FACES (1) BROKEN BRIDGES (1) BROOKE'S POINT (1) BUREAU OF CORRECTIONS (1) BUSINESS MIRROR (1) CADEM (1) CADET CUDIA (4) CALIDA (2) CANCELLATION OF ADOBE ACCOUNTS (1) CAPITAL (1) CARMEL MOUNTAIN (1) CARPIO DISSENT (2) CASA CORNELIA (2) CASE DURATION (1) casetext (1) CAUSE ORIENTED GROUPS (3) causes (4) CBCP (1) CELESTINO VIVIERO (1) CERES (2) CERTIFICATE OF SEPARATION (2) CHEATING (30) CHESS (4) CHRISTIANITY (1) Christmas (7) Christmas Hilltop (2) CHRONIC MENTAL LAPSES (1) CISP (4) CITO BELTRAN (1) CITY ATTORNEY (8) CIVIL RIGHTS (1) CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION (3) CJ SERENO COMIAL DISPLAY OF IRONY (1) CLAIM FILE (2) CLEOPATRA (1) climate change (6) CNN PARIS TERROR ATTACK (1) COAL (3) CODE OF CONDUCT AND ETHICAL STANDARDS(Republic Act No. 6713) (1) COGNITIVE LAZINESS (1) COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENT (1) COMEDY SKITS (4) COMELEC (2) COMMISSION APPOINTMENT (3) COMMONWEALTH ACT NO.3 (1) COMMUTE CHALLENGE (1) COMPLAINT AFFIDAVIT (1) COMPLIANCE COMMITTEE (2) ComPosPaper (29) con ed (26) CONCESSION AGREEMENT (15) CONDONATION DOCTRINE (2) CONED (68) CONFLICTING CONTRARY INFORMATION (3) CONGRESSIONAL HEARING ON ILLEGAL DRUGS (3) CONJUGAL DICTATORSHIP (1) CONNECTIONS.MIC (1) CONSTANT PARTIALITY (1) CONSTITUTION (26) CONSTITUTIONAL DOCTRINE OF CONSTITUTIONAL SUPREMACY (8) CONSTITUTIONAL CONCEPT OF ACCOUNTABILITY (1) CONTINUING VIOLATION DOCTRINE (8) CONTINUOUS TRIAL (1) CONTRACT OF SLAVERY (2) CORDILLERA 'MANSASAKUSA' (1) CORDILLERA 'PANGAT' (1) Corona Trial (5) CORPORATIZATION (1) CORRUPTION IN THE PHILIPPINES (11) COURT OF APPEALS (1) COURT OF TAX APPEALS (1) COVID-19 (3) CRISPIN BELTRAN (1) crude oil train fire (1) CUSTOMS (3) CYANIDE-LACED-SHABU (2) CYBER LIBEL (2) DAGIT AT SALUBONG (1) daily digg (27) Daily Kos (3) DAKOTA ACCESS PIPELINE (24) DALAI LAMA (1) DALAWANG BUAYA (1) DAMS AND EARTQUAKES (1) DANGAN (1) DARNA (1) DAVAO NIGHT MARKET (3) DAVIDE (1) DAVIES LAW GROUP (1) DEATH PENALTY (2) DEED OF SLAVERY (2) DEED OF SLAVERY (1) DELFIN LEE (1) DELIMA (14) DELIMA VS. GUERRERO ORAL ARGUMENTS (1) DEMAND PAYMENT (2) DEMENTIA (1) DENA EAKLES (1) DENMARK (1) DENNIS CAPILI (1) DENNIS DATU (1) DENR (12) DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH (1) DEPARTMENT OF INSURANCE (1) DEPARTMENT OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY (18) DERICK INN (1) DERYK INN (28) DESMOGBLOG.COM (2) DIRECTIVES (1) DISBARMENT (11) DISBARMENT PRIMER (1) discrimination (1) DISHONESTY (1) DJ RICHARD ENRIQUEZ (3) DJRICHARD (1) DOBLADA CASE (1) DOCTRINE OF CONSTITUTIONAL SUPREMACY (37) DOCTRINE OF FINALITY OF JUDGMENT (2) DOCTRINE OF SOVEREIGN IMMUNITY (2) DOG(MASCOT) (1) DOLE (1) dolphines (1) DON MOORE (1) DONALD TRUMP (15) DOS POR DOS (3) DOUBTFUL (2) Dr David Alameel (1) DR. JUAN ESCANDOR (1) Dr. Love...Tribute to Andy Williams (4) DRA.LULU (1) DRILON (2) DRONE SURFING (1) DRUG MATRIX (1) DUAL DYNAMICS OF CORRUPTION (1) DUBAI (1) DUCKS (1) DUE PROCESS (1) DUTERTE (89) DUTERTE COVID 19 (3) duterte impeachment (1) DUTERTE NEWS (4) DUTERTE SONA 2018 (1) DUTERTE SUPREME COURT APPOINTEES (1) DUTY TO INVESTIGATE (1) DYING LAWFUL DISCRETION (2) DZMM (13) DZMM SOUND BITES (2) EARTHQUAKE (3) EAT BULAGA (2) ECONOMIC SABOTAGE (2) EDD (1) EDDIE ATCHLEY (5) EDDIE GARCIA (4) EDGAR JOPSON (1) EDSA 1 (1) EDSA 4 (1) EFREN (25) EL SHADDAI (4) ELECTION (1) ELECTORAL COLLEGE (1) electric car (3) END OF THE AMERICAN DREAM (1) ENDO (2) ENERGY IN CAN (1) ENRILE (6) ENTREPRENEUR (1) ENTRY OF JUDGMENT (1) ENVIRONMENT (7) ERAP (1) ERWIN TULFO (1) ESPINOSA KILLING (1) ESPOSO (1) ESTAFA OR SWINDLING (1) ESTATE TAX (3) ESTELITO MENDOZA (2) EUGENE V. DEBS (1) EXCAVATION DEPTH (1) EXCAVATION FOR A FEE (1) EXHAUSTION OF THE SSS ADMINISTRATIVE REMEDIES (2) EXPLOSION (6) EXPOSE THE TPP (1) F-35 (1) FAILON (1) FAIR CLAIMS SETTLEMENT PRACTICES REGULATION (1) FAKE AMBUSH (1) FAMILY AND FRIENDS (1) FASAP VS. PAL (2) fascinating (1) FATIMA (1) FERNANDO POE JR. (1) FILIPIKNOW (4) FILIPINO SUBJECT (1) FILMS FOR ACTION (2) FIREWORKS (1) FIRST DRAFT (1) FIX THE COURT (3) flaring (4) flash (1) FOIA APPEAL (11) foia executive order by duterte (1) For Hon CJ Sereno (57) FORTUNE TOBACCO CORPORATION (1) fossil fuel (13) Fr. JERRY ORBOS (1) FR. JOAQUIN BERNAS (1) FR..ZACARIAS AGATEP (1) fracking (2) FRANCIS TOLENTINO (1) FREDDIE AGUILAR (1) Frederick Douglass (1) FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION REFERENCES (1) FREEDOM OF SPEECH (1) Friends from Tabangao (7) Frito_Lay (1) G-SPOT (1) GANDHI (1) GarageBand (1) GATES OPEN OR CLOSE (1) GB (3) GCTA (6) GEN. BATO (1) GENERAL BATO (1) GEORGE ORWELL (1) GEORGE SOROS (1) GERALD BANTAG (2) German artist (1) GERRY BAJA (1) GETTYSBURG ADDRESS REFERENCE (1) GEUS (1) GEUS REITERATION OF DEMAND PAYMENT (29) GIANT HULKBUSTER (1) GIANT SKELETONS (1) gifs (1) GILSON ACEVEDA (4) GINA LOPEZ (22) GIVE THANKS (1) GIZMODO (1) GLORIA (7) GMA News Online (1) gmo (3) GMO FREE USA (2) golan (1) Golden Gate views (7) GOP (3) GORDON (5) GOTCHA (1) GOUT (1) GRACE (1) GRACE POE (4) GRAND CONSPIRACY (2) GREAT ESCAPE (1) GREED (1) GREENPEACE (30) GREENPEACE VIDEOS (3) GRETCHEN HO (1) GRIT (1) GUENIOT EMAIL ADDRESS (1) GUIDE Back up (1) GUN VIOLENCE (1) HABITUAL CHEATING (5) HALAMANG GAMOT (6) HAPKIDO (1) Harriet Heywood (2) Harry Roque (25) Hatol (1) HEARSAY (3) HEFTY (1) HERITAGE LAW (1) HEROISM (3) HEYWOOD (1) HIAS (1) HILING NA PANG-UNAWA AT PANALANGIN (1) HITLER (1) HOME SOLAR (1) HONDA_COOPER (2) HOOVERBOARD (1) HORSE KICK (2) HOT PURSUIT (2) HOTLINE 8888 (6) HOTLINE 8888 _NOTICE ON BLOGS (1) HOUSE SOLAR PANELS (1) HUFF_POST BUSINESSS (1) HUFF_POST POLITICS (5) HUKUM BITAY (2) HUKUman (1) HUMAN RIGHTS (3) HUMAN RIGHTS CAMPAIGN (2) HUMAN RIGHTS ON LINE PHILIPPINES (3) HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH (7) humor (5) i am sorry (1) IA_MEDIA (19) IBP (2) IJREVIEW (2) ILLEGAL DRUGS (38) ILLUSTRATION BOARD (1) ILRF (3) IMAGES (3) IMAGES COLLECTION FROM FACEBOOK (16) IMELDA (1) Immigration reform (1) IMMUNITY FROM SUIT (1) impeachment (4) IMPEACHMENTDUE TO DELAY OF DISPOSITION OF CASES (1) IMPULSION (1) IN THESE TIMES (3) INAPPROPRIATE RESPONSE (117) INAUGURAL DUTERTE (2) Inay...Home (3) INC (2) INCRIMINATING SENTENCES (1) INDEPENDENCE DAY (1) InDesign (5) INDISCRETION OF A DYING MAN (3) INDOLENCE (1) INFOWARS (1) INJUSTICE (1) INORDINATE DELAY (1) INQUIRER (13) INQUIRY (66) INSPIRING (59) INSURANCE COMMISSIONER (1) INTELLIGENCE.COM (1) INTERAKSYON (1) International Labor Rights Forum (1) INTERNET FREEDOM (1) IOWA CITIZENS FOR COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT (1) IOWA CITY (1) ISLAM (1) ITALY (1) IUF (10) JACK LAM (3) JAIME (38) JAMES BWEIN (1) JANELLA SALVADOR (1) JANET LIM NAPOLES (1) JARIUS BONDOC (5) Jawaid Ali (2) JBC INTERVIEW. (6) JBC SHORTLIST (1) Jecjec's First birthday (9) Jecjec's first part (9) Jecjec's second part (9) Jecjec's third part (9) Jeffrey Pfeffer (1) JEFFREY WONG (1) Jehaziel Alburo (1) JENNIFER CHASE (4) JERICHO MARCH (1) JESUS (1) JILL STEIN (2) JIM THE EVANGELICAL PASTOR (2) JIMENO (1) JOEL CANO (8) JOEL CASTRO (12) JOEVER (1) John Donovan (1592) JOHN F. KENNEDY (1) JOHN LUNA (2) John MacMurray (1) JOHNY MAGBOO (1) JON STEWART (1) JOSE ABAD SANTOS (1) Jose Mujica (1) Jose Victoria (5) JOSEPH ESTRADA (1) JSTREET (1) JUDGE DISCIPLINE (1) JUDGE DISMISSAL (2) JUDGE FLORO (6) JUDGE MURO (3) JUDICIAL AND BAR COUNCIL (1) JULIET ALMONTERO ZAIDE (1) Jun Banaag (5) JUN ESPINA (1) JUNE 12 (1) JUSTICE ARTURO BRION (1) JUSTICE B. L. REYES (1) JUSTICE BERSAMIN (32) JUSTICE BRION (2) JUSTICE CARPIO (4) JUSTICE DEL CASTILLO (1) JUSTICE FELLOWSHIP (2) JUSTICE IMAGES (1) JUSTICE LEONEN (8) JUSTICE MARTIRES (20) JUSTICE MARVIN LEONEN (1) JUSTICE PEREZ (1) JUSTICE RUTH BADER GINSBURG (1) JUSTICE VELASCO (1) JUSTICES AS CLOWNS (1) JUSTICES VOTING PREFERENCE ON CORRUPTION (1) JUSTIN TRUDEAU (2) JUVIE PELOS UWAHIG (1) KA LOUIE TABING (2) KA PEPE (1) KAFAGUAY (1) KALIWA DAM PROJECT (2) KAMALA HARRIS (2) KAMPANA O MARTIAL LAW (1) KAREN DAVILA (2) KASPAROV (1) KEROSENE IN THE PHILIPPINES (1) KEYSTONE (1) KEYSTONE progress (1) KEYSTONE XL PIPELINE (5) KICK BIG POLLUTERS OUT (1) KIDNAP FOR RANSOM (1) KOBE BRYANT (1) KOCH BROTHERS (7) KOREAN LANGUAGE (1) KUYA MIKE (1) KUYA'S PRACTICE PROJECT (1) LA LONTOC DECISION (6) LA PROGRESSIVE (261) LABOR (2) LABOR DAY (1) LABOR UNIONS (19) LabourStart (2) LAGMAN VS. MEDIALDEA (1) LAGUNA DE BAY (1) LAPITAN (16) LAPU-LAPU (1) LARRY WINES (1) LATINOS PRO BERNIE SANDERS (1) LAUGHTER (1) LAW (4) LAW PREVAILS OVER IR/AGREEMENT (2) lawsuit vs. shell (2) Layusa (1) LEAGUE OF CITIES IN THE PHILIPPINES (2) LEAGUE OF CITIES OF THE PHILIPPINES (LCP) VS. COMELEC (1) LED ZEPPELIN (1) LENNY ROBREDO (7) LEON LEYNES (1) LEONARDO RAMOS (3) LETTER COMPLAINT (1) LETTY JIMENEZ-MAGSANOC (1) Leyte1897 (1) LIA SAFANOVA (1) LILIOSA HILAO (1) LIP SERVICE (1) LIST OF INFORMATION (4) lito (1) LITTLE THINGS.COM (2) LIU (9) LIVE VIDEO FOOTAGES (1) LIWAYWAY VINSONS-CHATO (1) LIZA MAZA (1) LIZA SOBERANO (1) LOBO MINING (2) Loise Slaughter (1) LOST CM ENVELOPS (3) LOURDES (2) MABILIN (1) MABINI (1) MAGALONG (2) MAGIC KINGDOM (2) MAGIIC (1) MAGUINDANAO MASSACRE (2) MAHAL NA ARAW (1) MAHAWI MAN ANG ULAP (2) MAINE MENDOZA (1) MAMMOGRAMS (1) MANAGEMENT PREROGATIVE (2) MANDAMUS (2) mandela (1) MANEJA (1) MANILA BAY (1) MANILA BAY CLEAN UP (4) MANILA BAY DREDGING (4) MANILA BAY RECLAMATION (14) Manila street view (1) MANILA TIMES (4) MANILA WATER (24) Manny Pacman Pacquiao Para sa yo ang laban nato (1) MARCOLETA LOPEZ (2) MARCOS (84) MARCOS BURIAL ORAL ARGUMENTS (6) Maren's baby shower video (10) Maren's bs p.1 (8) Maren's bs p.2 (7) MARIAN RIVERA-DANTES (1) MARIJUANA (1) MARIO SIBUCAO (4) Mark 12:28-34 (1) MARTIAL LAW (5) MARTIAL LAW ORAL ARGUMENTS (1) MARTIAL LAW IN MINDANAO (1) MARTIAL LAW IN MINDANAO ORAL ARGUMENTS (3) MARY JANE VELOSO (1) MARYJANE VELOSO (1) Maya Angelou (1) MAYNILAD (24) MAYOR SANCHEZ (2) MELANIE JONES (1) MERCENARY (1) MICHAEL BRUNE (1) MIDAS MARQUEZ (2) MIKE ENRIQUEZ (1) MILAN. ITALY (1) Mimi Moore (12) MINDANAO MARTIAL LAW (2) MINING (9) MIRA MESA NEIGHBORHOOD (2) Miranda Cosgrove (1) MISPLACED PRORITIES (1) Miss Philippines Pia Alonzo Wurtzbach (2) MISS UNIVERSE2017 (1) MMDA CHAIRMAN RESIGN (2) MMK (1) MNN WEEKLY (45) MONEY (1) MONEY LAUNDERING (2) MONEYTALK (1) MONSANTO (1) Mosses (49) MOST COMMONLY MISUSED ENGLISH WORDS (1) MOTHER JONES (31) MOTHER NATURE NETWORK (2) MOTHER TERESA (1) Motion for Recon with links (1) motion for reconsideration (5) Mount Vesuvius (1) MoveOn (7) MOVEON.ORG (15) MOYERS & COMPANY (1) MR(NEW) (1) MRFF (1) MRT (1) MTRCB (1) MULTIPLE TRANSGRESSION (1) MUSIC ALBUM ON DISASTER PREPAREDNESS (1) MUTUAL BUSINESS PARTNERSHIP (4) MWSS (1) MY BIRTHDAY CAKE (1) NADINE LUSTRE (1) NALUNDASAN (1) NASA'S JUNO SPACECRAFT (1) NATION (112) NATION OF CHANGE (32) NATIONAL HEROES DAY (1) NATIONAL PARKS (3) NATIONof CHANGE (3) NAZRENO (1) NBC NEWS (1) NBI (1) NCLR (1) NEIL YOUNG (1) NERI COLMINARES (1) NESTOR (1) NET NEUTRALITY (7) NEW FUEL SYSTEM (1) NEW YORK TIMES (6) NEW YORKER (1) NEW ZEALAND (1) NEWS (192) NEWS MIC (1) NEWS+STORIES (1) NEWSLETTERS (1) NEWSWEEK (1) NICOLAS FERNANDO (5) NIGER DELTA (2) NINJA COPS (3) NLRC DECISION (1) NLRC RESOLUTION (1) NO EMAIL SENT (1) NOAH'S ARK (1) NOEL TIJAM (1) NOLI S. ATIENZA (2) NONOY ZUNIGA (1) NORTH KOREA (1) NOT VERIFIED DISBARMENT COMPLAINT (1) NOT1MORE (1) NOTICE ON CHANGE OF EMAIL ADDRESS (1) NRDC (4) NUCLEAR AGE PEACE FOUNDATION (1) NUGGETS (1) NURSES FOR CHANGE (1) NUTRITION ACTION (1) NWF (1) obama (3) Obama Victory Speech (1) OBJECTION ON MATTER SENDING NOTICE (27) OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE (1) OCCUPY DEMOCRATS.COM (3) OCCUPY.COM (1) OCEAN CONSERVANCY (5) OCEAN RIVER INSTITUTE (4) OCEANA (1) OFFSHORE WIND FARMS (1) OIL CHANGE INTERNATIONAL (5) OIL DEREGULATION (1) OILANDGASPEOPLE (1) oiled hand (1) OLD DOG TRICK (1) OLIGARCHY (2) Oliveros (1) OMBUDSMAN (2) OMBUDSMAN MORALES (1) on Kabayan (1) ONE MILLION PAGEVIEWS (1) ONE YEAR SUIT (1) OneForPacman (1) ONSEHAN (1) OPEN MEDIA (1) ORAL ARGUMENTS (2) ORDER-OMBUSMAN (1) ORGANIC BYTES (6) other98 (4) OUR CITY (1) OVER IM VIEWS (10) OVERTURN THE SUPREME COURT (1) pachelbel's Canon in D (1) Packet (13) PACQUIAO (2) PADRE PIO (2) PALACE JOKES (1) PALEA (5) palm oil docu (1) PALSA (1) PANDORA'S BOX (2) PANELO (9) PANGILINAN (25) PAO CHIEF ACOSTA (2) papaya (1) parabolc solar collectors (1) PARTIDO NG MANGGAGAWA (5) PARTY TO TITOUAH'S CRIMES (3) PATENT (18) PATHOLOGICAL LIAR (1) PATRIOT DIRECT (1) Pau Gasol (1) PAUL GEORGE (1) PAUL WATSON (5) PAULINE MARIE (1) PCIJ (1) PDAF (1) PENAL CODE 31 (1) PENAL CODE 368 (1) PEOPLE DEMANDING ACTION (2) people power (4) PERJURY (1) PERSUASIVE APPEALS/REMINDERS (917) peru (1) PETA (8) PHILIPPINE AIRLINES (4) PHILIPPINE JUSTICE SYSTEM (2) PHILSTAR HEADLINES (1) PHILSTAR OPINION (2) PHONY PHONICS (1) PHOTO MEDIA SHEET (1) photo petition (1) photoshop (7) PICTURES (1) PINAS TRENDING (1) PINOY TRENDING NEWS (1) PIO CHIEF THEODORE TE (2) PITTSBURG POST GAZZETTE (1) PIZARRO (26) PLANNED OPERATION (1) PLANNED PARENTHOOD (7) PLASTIC TO FUEL (1) plunder (1) PMA (1) PMA HONOR CODE REIGN SUPREME OVER THE CONSTITUTION (22) PNOY (2) POE (1) POGO BLOG (17) POLARIS (2) POLICY BOOKLET (8) POLICY DEFENSE (5) POLICY MIC (9) POLITICO (7) POLITICO MAGAZINE (1) POLITICUS_USA (154) POLITIKO (6) POLY DE CASTRO (1) POPE FRANCIS (22) POPULATION CONNECTION (1) POPULATION EXPLOSION (1) PORK BARREL (1) POSITION UNCHANGED (1) POSTAL BANKING (1) POTASSIUM CYANIDE (2) POWER IN CANS (1) POWER OF POSITIVITY (1) POWER OF WIND (4) PRAY FOR THE WORLD (1) PRAYER VS. DEATH PENALTY (1) Prelude (1) Premiere Pro (3) premierepro (2) PREPONDERANCE (1) PRESUMPTION OF REGULARITY (1) PRINCIPAL AGENT RELATION (1) PRIVATE EQUITY (1) PRO CORRUPTION CONDONATION DOCTRINE (1) PRO LABOR ALLIANCE INC (2) PROCLAMATION NO. 1959 (1) PROCLAMATION NO. 216 (1) PROVOCATIVE ART (1) ps (7) PSR (1) PUBLIC CITIZEN (3) PUBLIC OFFICIALS AND EMPLOYEES DUTIES (1) PUBLIC SERVICE (1) PUNZI PUNZALAN (12) QUERIES (29) QUESTIONS FOR MR. LIU (43) QUESTIONS FOR MR. LIU SUMMARY (1) QUIROZ MISLED THE COURT (6) QUIT COAL (6) QUO WARRANTO PETITION (10) RA 10066 (1) RA 1161 (1) RA 3019 (3) RA 7641 CIRCUMVENTED BY SHELL (11) RA-8282 (1) RACISM (1) RADYO INQUIRER (1) RATTLED PLUMBER (1) RAW STORY (1) READER SAN DIEGO COVER DESIGNING (2) READING EAGLE (1) REASONS FOR DENIAL (2) RED-HERRING (1) REEVES AND ASSOCIATE (1) REFERENCE (1) REFERENCES (77) reggie watts (1) REITERATION SERIES (15) REJECT RPT20 MOVEMENT (5) REJOINDER (26) RELIGIOUS FREEDOM CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS (1) REMINDER SERIES (15) REMORSE AND EMPATHY (1) RENAISSANCE OF THE COURT (1) RENEWABLE ENERGY (23) REP. ALAN GRAYSON (17) REPLY (13) REPRESENT US (2) REPUBLICANS (1) RETROSPECTION (9) REVEAL (1) REWRITING DENIAL LETTERS (1) RHONDA KESTEN (1) RICHARD ENRIQUEZ (1) Rick Kissell (1) RICO BERSAMIN (3) RICO J. PUNO (1) RIGGED RANKING (1) RIGHT TO WORK (2) RING OF FIRE (4) RITCHE CORONEL (1) RIZAL (2) RIZAL BURIAL WISHES (1) RIZAL TRIAL AND EXECUTION (1) ROBERT KENNEDY (1) Robert Naiman (1) ROBERT PLANT (1) ROBERT REICH (102) robin williams (1) robredo (1) RODOLFO ARIZALA (1) Roel Manlangit on Rated Korina (2) ROLANDO TOLENTINO (1) ROMY DELA CRUZ (1) RON DRUYAN (1) ROOSTER NEW YEAR (1) RootsAction (5) RUGBY (1) RUN FOR THE SEALS (1) SA BREAKING NEWS (1) SA KABUKIRAN (1) safety (4) SALN (28) SALON (3) Salvador Escodero III (1) same sex marriage (1) SAMUEL MARTIRES (3) SAN DIEGO FREE PRESS (79) SAN DIEGO FBI (3) San Francisco (13) SAN JOSE MERCURY NEWS (1) San Ramon travel (4) SANDY HOOK (1) SANOFI (1) SARA DUTERTE (1) satire (2) SATUR OCAMPO (1) SAVE THE ARCTIC (5) save the internet (5) SAVING CAPITALISM (2) SCAM (1) SCHOLARSHIP ESSAY (1) science (1) SCOTT PETERS (1) SCP JUSTICES SALN REPORT (2) SCRIBD (1) SEA SHEPHERD (2) SEAL CONSERVANCY OF SAN DIEGO (1) Section 2695.5 (e) (2) (4) SECTION 2695.5(b) (1) SEIU (1) SELF AGGRANDIZEMENT (1) SELF-DEFENSE (1) Sen Santiago (2) SEN. BERNIE SANDERS (363) SENATE (4) SenChiz (12) SenChiz videos (3) separation pay (1) separation pay/retirement pay (1) SEPTEMBER MORN (1) SERENO (23) SERENO _PETITION DOCUMENT 1 A.C.NO. 10084 (12) SERENO DISSENT (3) SERENO_stopworking in silos (1) SERENO_TWEETER ACCOUNT (2) SERVICE OFFER (5) SET OF FOLLOW UP-EMAILS DATED MARCH 15 (5) SETTLEMENT AMOUNT (21) SEX (7) SHABU (19) SHADOW OF DOUBT (1) SHAM AWARDS (1) SHAME (1) SHAMELESS BISHOPS (1) SHEL (1) SHELL (50) SHELL 100TH YEAR (1) SHELL GENERAL BUSINESS PRINCIPLES (1) SHELL HIRING (1) SHELL IPO (2) SHELL IS ABOVE THE LAW (53) SHELL rejoinder (1) SHELL SCAM (5) SHELL SMUGGLING (7) SHELL SWINDLING (1) SHELL VS. BOC (1) ShellPosPaper (22) SHERWIN LUMANGLAS (1) SHOOTING IN OREGON (1) short story (3) Sie and Mia (2) Sierra Club (25) SIERRA RISE (1) SINKHOLE (1) SKETCHES (1) SLEEP MUSIC RELAX (1) SMART CARS BODY KITS (1) SMILE TRAIN (2) SNAKES (1) SOCIAL INJUSTICE (1) SOCIAL JUSTICE (1) SOCIAL SECURITY (1) SOCIAL SECURITY WORKS (9) SOCRATES VILLEGAS (1) SOFT SPOT (1) SOLAR (18) SOLAR BOTTLE STREET LAMPS (1) SOLAR ENERGY (2) SOLAR PANELS (1) SOLAR POWER (2) solar roadways (2) SOLO WHEEL (1) SONA (3) SONA NI PNOY (4) SONG (1) SOP FOR ARTBOARD (1) sopa (1) SOUND (2) SOWING CONFUSION (14) SPECIFIC DOCUMENT (3) SPINELESS ALIBI (1) SPIRIT (1) spiritual (1) SSS (13) STAIRWAY TO HEAVEN (2) STALLONE (1) STAND UP TO ALEC (1) Standing Rock Sioux Tribe v. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (1) STATE FARM DENIAL LETTERS (11) STATE FARM FILE UPLOAD REQUEST (4) storm surge (1) StumbleUpon (28) STYROFOAM-EATING WORMS (1) SumOfUs (7) SUNCARGO (1) SUNDAY TV MASS (1) SUNTIMES (1) SUPERMOON (3) SuperPAC (1) SUPREME COURT (7) SUPREME COURT AC 10084 (3) SUPREME COURT DECISIONS (1) SUPREME COURT E-MAIL ADDRESS INQUIRY (52) Susan Graves (1) SWEAR (2) SWINDLING CRIMINAL COMPLAINT (1) SY-JOSE MEDINA (57) SYNDICATED ESTAFA (6) TAAL VOLCANO (4) TAGA BAUAN (1) TAKE MEASUREMENTS (1) TAKEPART (4) TANIM-BALA (1) TASREA VS. SHELL (2) TAURUS (1) TAX FAIRNESS (2) TAX HAVENS (1) TAXATION (2) TAXING CARBON (1) Team Brad (1) TEAM USA (1) TEASER COMPILATION (15) TEASERS 17OCT18 TO 31JAN19 (1) TECHNICALITIES (1) TECHNOLOGY (18) TED FAILON (2) TERESITA (10) TESLA (2) TESLA CHANNEL (1) tessie (1) THANKSGIVING (1) THE ACTION NETWORK (1) The Atlantic (1) THE HILL (4) THE HUMAN SOCIETY (1) THE HUMANE SOCIETY (1) The Institute for Inclusive Security (2) THE MAHARLIKAN (1) THE NATURE CONSERVANCY (5) the ONION (2) THE SCREWERS (1) THE STAMPEDE (1) the stranger (1) THE SUNFLOWER (2) THE TRUST for PUBLIC LAND (1) the VOICE (1) THE WASHINGTON POST (1) THIEFDOM (1) THINK PROGRESS (146) THIRD YEAR CLASS (2) THOMAS PAINE (1) TIA NENA (1) tia nene (5) Tia Nene ...MMK Drama (2) Tia Nene...MMK Drama (1) Tia Nene..MMK Drama (1) TIFFANI WYATT (4) TIGLAO (1) TIM BAYLEN (1) TIME LAPSE (2) TING GOL TOK (1) TOADS (1) TOM HOWARD (2) TOM STEYER (1) tonton (3) TOP 1% (1) TOP GEAR PHILIPPINES (1) TORRE DE MANILA (1) TOURISM (41) TPO (27) TPO EXAM STUDY GUIDE (1) TPP (51) TQ Solis (1) TRANS-PACIFIC PARTNERSHIP (1) TRANSCANADA PIPELINE EXPLOSION (1) TRASLACION 2018 (1) TRIBULATION NOW (1) TRICYCLE (1) TRO (1) TRUTH (1) TTA (1) TTP (2) TUGON (1) TURKEYS (1) TYRANNY (1) U.N. (1) Ua trestel (1) UltraViolet Action (2) UNION OF CONCERNED SCIENTISTS (7) UNIQUE FACTS (1) UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME (1) UP COLLEGE OF LAW (1) UPDATE REQUEST (1) UPWORTHY (168) URBAN MIGRATION (1) URGENDA (1) US (1) US POLITICS (2) USEFUL TIPS (1) USnews (1) vagina (1) VALVE NOT FULLY OPENED (1) VANDALISM (6) VANDANA SHIVA (1) VATICAN INSIDER (1) Veit Stumpenhausen (1) VELASCO PONENCIA (1) VERBAL STATEMENTS (3) VETERANS DAY (1) VICE GANDA (1) Vidal (1) VIDEOS 1M+ PAGEVIEWS (73) VILLAFUERTE (1) Visit to Tito Nestor (1) Vitangcol (1) VITUG (1) VOICES FOR PUBLIC TRANSIT (1) volcano eruption (2) VOX (3) VP BINAY (2) VPletter (2) wall street (3) WAR ON DRUGS (2) WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY (1) WATCHDOG.NET (4) WATER DAMAGES (2) WATER FOR PEOPLE (1) WATER PURIFIER (2) weighing scale (1) WEST PHILIPPINE SEA (1) WHALE SLAUGHTER (1) WHO IS (2) WHO IS IN CHARGE OVER YOU (1) WIKIPEDIA (1) WILDERNESS WATCH (1) WILFUL IGNORANCE (1) WIND (6) Wind generators (1) WORLD MIC (1) world war II (1) WORLDNEWSDAILYREPORT (1) WRIT OF HABEAS DATA (1) WWTP (339) YAHOO NEWS (1) YNARES-SANTIAGO (1) YOLY ORDONEZ ALCARAZ (4) YU (1) ZAMORA (1) ZFAMOSSES (5) ZMOSSES (431)
; ;